Where to Fish

General Information

General access tools that you should bookmark on your phone.

Connecticut

Nearby CT has some premier trout fishing and is doable in a day trip!

  • Farmington River (West Branch) – Trout Management Areas
    Cold, bottom-release tailwater with year-round trout fishing; three Trout Managment Area sections with specific gear/harvest rules. Species: wild/big browns, stocked rainbows. Time from NYC: ~2–3 hours by car, limited car-free combos (train + rideshare). Use DEEP Trout Management Areas site, then check flows on USGS CT DEEP Trout Management Areas

  • Saugatuck / Mianus (coastal TMAs & classically stocked streams)
    Good spring/fall options near Metro-North towns, Stamford, CT 🡪 uber. 1 hr from Harlem 125th to the water; Confirm current regs & access via DEEP “Where to Fish” map + stocking updates. CT DEEP Where to Fish

NYC Car Free Options

Live in NYC and don’t have a car? You still have some options!

  • Harlem Meer (Central Park) – Carp, panfish, bass. Easy subway/bus. Follow NYC Parks rules. Time from mid-Manhattan: ~10–25 min transit. NYC Parks Central Park Fishing

  • Prospect Park Lake (Brooklyn) – Largemouth bass, panfish, occasional pickerel. Time from mid-Manhattan: ~20–40 min via subway. NYC Parks Prospect Park Fishing

  • Van Cortlandt Lake (Bronx) – Bass/carp/panfish; multiple shoreline access points. Time from mid-Manhattan: ~30–50 min via subway. NYC Parks Van Cortland Park Fishing

  • Jamaica Bay (salt) – Wading/spots along shorelines for schoolie stripers/bluefish (check tides!). Time from mid-Manhattan: ~40–70 min transit + walk.. NYC Parks Jamaica Bay Fishing

  • East / West Branch Croton River (Brewster) – Brown trout, rainbow trout, carp, panfish. Metro-North to Brewster 🡪 taxi / walk / bike. 

  • Amawalk River – Wild brown trout, wild rainbow. Metro-North to Katonah 🡪 walk, bike, taxi, uber. Fishing In Westchester County

Species and Match the Hatch

This is a short list of local spots and what fish you can best target at those spots.

Long Island Day Trips

Have a little more time and want to get out to Long Island?

  • Connetquot River State Park Preserve (East Islip)Fly-fishing only spring-creek experience with reservation system. Species: stocked browns/rainbows that often behave like spring-creek fish. Getting there: LIRR to Great River, short rideshare to gate, or drive. Connetquot River State Park Info

  • Southaven County Park area - Carmans River – Trout in season; also warmwater stretches. Use DEC maps and county access info. Suffolk County Parks Info

  • South Shore surf (Jones Beach / Fire Island) – Striped bass/bluefish (spring/fall runs).

Quick Prep Checklist

Make sure you are ready before heading out!

  • Be Legal!

  • Check Flows, Tides, Stocking the night before

  • Pack accordingly

    • Trout

      • 4–5 weight,

      • nymphs/drys/streamers

    • Carp / Bass

      • 6-8 weight

      • buggers, crawdads, poppers

    • Saltwater

      • 7-9 weight

      • Wading belt

      • Stripping basket